Written by • 5:34 pm• Anything Fly Fishing • One Comment

The Truth About Fly Fishing

“You like to tell true stories?” he asked and I answered, “Yes, I like to tell stories that are true.” Then he asked, “After you have finished your true stories sometime, why don’t you make up a story and the people to go with it? Only then will you understand what happened and why.”
-Norman Maclean, A River Runs Through It

If only we had asked our children the same questions that Reverend Maclean asked his son, Norman, things may have turned out a lot differently. It’s taken me, and I suspect most of us, a lifetime to “understand what happened and why.” Stories about fly fishing help to make it possible.

I’ve spent over fifty years wading rivers across the country, devouring the meditative literature of fly fishing, teaching life lessons from the stream, searching for “truth.” Thomas McGuane had it right, or so I thought, that happiness and purpose flowed from deeper, more truthful self-understanding, and that fly fishing could lend a hand. He wrote, in The Longest Silence: A Life in Fishing, that fly fishing taught him “how to look at people, myself included,” and he encouraged us all to use the sport “to arouse greater reverberations within ourselves.”

Other notable fly fishing authors also focus on self-awareness as an important element of the experience. While they approach the theme somewhat differently, all agree that fly fishing uncovers a path to deeper self-understanding. Steve Ramirez contemplates in Casting Forward: Fishing Tales from the Texas Hill Country, “Whenever I see my own reflection, I see what is behind the lines that radiate from weary eyes.” Harry Middleton, in The Earth is Enough: Growing Up in a World of Fly Fishing, Trout, and Old Men, reminds us that fishing’s reward “was angling itself, just meeting the trout in its world, on its own terms, feeling the tenuous nature of its life and suddenly understanding the tenuousness of your own.” Wayne Fields, writing about a painful, but transformative period of his life in What the River Knows: An Angler in Midstream, ruminates that “To sit by a river is to enjoy the fittest place for contemplation even as one awaits a struggle with whatever monster might reside within those depths.” And Robert DeMott, in Angling Days: A Fly Fisher’ Journals, acknowledges that “More and more, I realize the truth of Thoreau’s proclamation that we fish all our lives without knowing that it isn’t fish we are really after. It’s something deeper, larger, and more lasting.” As Mark Browning summarizes in Haunted by Waters: Fly Fishing in North American Literature, “The pinnacle of fly-fishing methodology as presented in the works of many of its most celebrated writers is found in the paradox of what the angler is actually pursuing. Far from the simple pursuit of fish, the best angler pursues self-awareness.”

It goes without saying that fly fishing isn’t the only path to self-understanding. For thousands of years, restorative self-knowledge has occupied the minds of philosophers, psychologists, scientists, educators, and countless numbers of artists and humanists. Remember Socrates’ timeless instruction: “Know thyself.” Personally, I’ve always been drawn to writer and teacher Jill Kerr Conway’s explanation of self-discovery, writing in her memoir, The Road to Coorain: “All of us live with a life history in our mind, and very few of us subject it to critical analysis. But we are storytelling creatures. So it’s very important to examine your own story and make sure that the plot is the one you really want.”

But more than self-understanding, the literature of fly fishing also reinforces the social and communal nature of our passion. Whether it’s couched as human companionship, ecological responsibility, or a higher spiritual and cosmological order, fly fishing writers envision its potential to reimagine the collective. Ted Leeson, in The Gift of Trout, writes, “The trout is inseparable from larger and more inclusive worlds … at the center of an intricate and expansive system of connections—to the intriguing, half-understood universe of a trout stream; to the entire natural world; to an historical tradition; an ethic; a social and environmental responsibility; to personal meanings; and to a thousand other things of value.” In another Leeson memoir, Jerusalem Creek: Journeys into Driftless Country, he declares “Both solitude and society are improved on a trout stream.” Steve Ramirez reminds us in Casting Onward: Fishing Adventures in Search of America’s Native Gamefish that “Everything is connected…. This book is about more than fish, it’s about people…. It’s about friendship and pulling together for some common good.” Returning to Mark Browning Browning’s analysis of fly fishing literature, Haunted by Waters, “Just as fly fishing provides a locus for the merging of the worlds of air and water, so, in a larger sense, does it provide a vehicle for the forging of a great number of relationships or connections…. a connection between the angler and deeper insight…. between the angler and the self, the angler and society at large.” More than a path to self-reflection, then, fly fishing also is a mirror on the world, engaging us with all aspects of our collective lives.

As I’ve outlined above, the lessons of fly fishing and its literature reside in an appeal to better understand ourselves, others, and the world. These stories from the stream nurture both personal and collective insight, and they invite us to bridge our interior and exterior landscapes, our inner and outer worlds, and by extension, what is subjective and what is objective—how we see things and how they really are.

But the most profound and perplexing lesson is that fly fishing, like most of life, takes us in between our inner and outer worlds to locate, the best we can, “what happened and why”—the truth. Does this suggest that truth is contextual, based on our beliefs and perceptions of an event or an idea, or on particular circumstances and settings? I don’t believe so. After all, there are things that are universally and timelessly true, like the warmth of a campfire, the chill of a mountain stream, the unconditional love for a child, and yes, the “self-evident” truths guaranteed by our Declaration of Independence—equality, life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. However, in the realms of intrapersonal, social, and cultural dynamics, there are limitations to our fully understanding and accepting the unclear, nuanced truth of the matter, which is snarled by psychological and social hurdles, both self-imposed and external. Truth, in those domains, is neither purely subjective nor is it wholly impartial. It’s precariously in between, but worth taking the plunge and navigating. The Jungian psychoanalyst James Hollis wrote in Living Between Worlds: Finding Personal Resilience in Changing Times that our most challenging but rewarding personal journey is “living between worlds,” where “In those moments we transcend the opposites that tear us apart … to grow larger.”

All of this is prologue to a few important principles about truth, and more specifically, its imperfect nature, that Norman Maclean understood when he penned A River Runs Through It: “Many of us would probably be better fishermen if we did not spend so much time watching and waiting for the world to become perfect.” We are imperfect and live in an imperfect world, and that’s the most we can grasp about truth, despite searching for something larger. Just as valuable: seeking wisdom to accept this, rather than some absolute sense of truth, is a more productive approach to a life of happiness and purpose. And finally, this wisdom “to grow larger” as James Hollis suggested, can be found “living between worlds.”

John Cawelti, a colleague of Norman Maclean when he taught at the University of Chicago, wrote about two key symbols—water and words—that are the chief expression of A River Runs Through It from start to finish that constitute the enduring power of the story. “The river is the background of the story and is associated with the flow of experience, with nature, and also with our memories of the past that continually flow into the present and sometimes threaten to drown us. Words are our attempts to understand, to deal with, and to control insofar as we are able, the flow of life.” In other words, somewhere between the water and the words, between all we’re unable to control and all we wish we could—“between worlds”—lies the imperfect truth, and the best we can achieve is the wisdom to accept that.

More than a reason for writing stories about fly fishing, this search for what lies between the water and the words—for what “what really happened”—is an “investigation into what it means to be a human being,” according to Robert Browning in Haunted by Waters: Fly Fishing in North American Literature. I’ll take this a step further and suggest, as Peter Jarvis does in his book Paradoxes of Learning, that this “investigation” is tantamount to the deepest forms of learning, the kind that mines the many contradictions that shape the human condition. Jarvis writes that “learning begins with a fundamental disjuncture between individual biography and the socially constructed experience…. Yet the process of questioning is itself a paradox for an uncertain humankind in continual search of certainty.” What’s between the water and the words, the angler’s penultimate paradox, is consistent with Jarvis’ description of learning that is “formulated with the framework of paradox since the idea of self-contradictoriness in human existence is crucial: in life, there is death; in joy, sorrow; in freedom, a fear of freedom; in constraint, frustration; and so on …. Learning, then, is not straightforward but complex and even contradictory.”

Stories about fly fishing, then, help us navigate this world of contradiction and paradox, and as a mirror on our world, they, too, reflect the dilemmas and frustrations in discerning what is true. “In the end,” writes Ted Leeson in Jerusalem Creek: Journeys Into Driftless Country, “it is all about stories. A trout fly is only a story we invent … an explanation of what we think we understand…. And when our stories fail, as all eventually do, we sift our failures for clues and … make up a new story, hoping to converge on some truth of the matter even as we know that is impossible, and settling as we must for the best of all possible lies.” Similarly, Robert DeMott in Angling Days: A Fly Fisher’s Journals, concludes “Fisherman are notorious liars … but really we are all relentless elaborators, seeking explanations for why we fish and what we fish for.” Referencing Norman Maclean’s novella, DeMott writes that “the river that ‘runs through it’ … is also the river of narrative, the rush and tumble of language, the unimpeded flow of a contextual story that binds together experience … and creates a running thread of participatory, immersive knowledge. Fly Fishing is tailor-made for our story-obsessed culture.”

Returning to the epigraph from A River Runs Through It, cited at the top of this essay, can we ever fully “understand what happened and why”? Can we really know the truth? What the literature of fly fishing teaches, much like the literature of transformative learning and analytic psychology, is that a fundamental task of adulthood is to learn how to reside “between worlds,” in the gray spaces of complexity, uncertainty, and vulnerability where most of us live and work, especially during those unsettling and disorienting times that comprise the paradox of the human condition. The central tenet of A River Runs Through It and, I suggest, purposeful and thoughtful adult life, is the capacity to enter those spaces where, as Maclean writes, “everything is luminous but not clear.”

These spaces, and the stories they generate, are more storehouses of wisdom and courage than placeholders of truth. Norman Maclean would never fully understand the truth behind his brother Paul’s tragic death, but finally, after years of searching and hoping, he learned to accept, and perhaps even embrace, this fragile and imperfect ground. That takes wisdom, humility, and courage. These are the qualities that inspired Maclean to end his story on a hopeful note: “Eventually, all things merge into one, and a river runs through it.” But there’s more to it, like our own story today, living in an imperfect world where truth is fleeting and can bend to the power of perception and persuasion. A River Runs Through It captures this dilemma with a closing line that tempers hope with stark acceptance and, perhaps, even a warning: “I am haunted by waters.”

There’s never been a more opportune time to summon all the wisdom and courage we can to pay close attention to this important lesson from the stream, to live more freely between worlds where “everything is luminous but not clear,” and to heed Reverend Maclean’s firm and loving declaration to his son: “Only then will you understand what happened and why.” Maybe each of us still has a true story to tell, and that things will turn out differently.

Visited 165 times, 1 visit(s) today
↑
Close